|
Abstract:
|
Nationally, the academic performance of Hispanic students
is considerably below majority norms. According to
the President's Advisory Commission on Educational
Excellence for Hispanic Americans (2003), the nation
is "losing Hispanic American students all along the
education continuum" (p.1). The Commission has further
warned that the present crisis in educating Hispanic
children threatens the ability of the United States
to compete economically. Of particular concern is
the serious shortfall in the number of Hispanic students
entering the science, mathematics, engineering, and
technology (SMET) fields. Two-way bilingual programs
(a.k.a. dual language education programs) are designed
to provide a high quality educational experience for
language minority students and to promote higher levels
of academic achievement (Lindholm-Leary, 2001; Lindholm-Leary
& Borsato, 2001). Two-way programs integrate native
English-speaking students and native-Spanish speaking
students and all content instruction is administered
through both languages. The extant research indicates
that two-way programs that are implemented correctly
have very positive student outcomes at the elementary
and early middle school levels. However, there is
a dearth of findings regarding the impact that two-way
bilingual programs have on academic outcomes at the
high school level, and particularly whether it improves
the success of students who entered school with limited
English proficiency. The purpose of this study is
to examine Hispanic high school students who had participated
in a two-way program in elementary school, with respect
to their performance in and attitudes toward mathematics
and school. A total of 134 ninth-grade through twelfth-grade
students participated in the study; they were categorized
into one of three groups on the basis of their ethnicity
and their language background (89 Hispanic Spanish-speakers,
27 Hispanic English-speakers, and 18 Euro American
English-speakers). Students in the three groups differed
significantly in their mothers' level of education
( 2 = 42.0, p < .001): higher levels of mom's education
were represented among Euro students, and the lowest
levels of education represented among Hispanic Spanish
speakers. All students in the study completed a questionnaire
that comprised questions concerning attitudes toward
school, current schooling path and college ambitions,
and parent and teacher support. Most of these items
were rated on a five point Likert scale ranging from
"strongly disagree" (1) to "strongly agree" (5). Results
suggest that students who participated in the two-way
bilingual program intend not to drop out of school,
have the desire to attend college, understand the
importance of getting good grades, have positive academic
attitudes, and perceive that they received a better
education in the two-way program and that they are
doing at least as well as their non-two-way peers.
In addition, the students scored average to slightly
below average on standardized tests of mathematics
in middle school, they are currently enrolled in higher-level
math courses in which they receive average grades,
and they have positive attitudes toward math. These
results suggest that the two-way bilingual program
may provide the academic preparation and schooling
attitudes, even in mathematics, that enable these
students to be more successful than the average at-risk
Hispanic and low socio-economic status students described
in the literature.
References
- Lindholm-Leary, K. J. (2001). Dual language education.
Avon, England: Multilingual Matters.
- Lindholm-Leary, K. J. (2001), & Borsato, G. (2001).
Impact of two-way bilingual elementary programs on
students' attitudes toward school and college. Santa
Cruz, CA: Center for Research on Education, Diversity
& Excellence.
- Presidential Advisory Commission on Educational
Excellence for Hispanic Americans (2003). From risk
to opportunity: Fulfilling the educational needs of
Hispanic Americans in the 21st century. Retrieved
July 31, 2003 from www.yic.gov/paceea/finalreport.pdf
|